American Alpine Jounrna and Accidents in North American Climbing

Fall on Ice – Fatigue, Dehydration

New York, Adirondacks, Chapel Pond

  • Accident Reports
  • Author: Matt Horner
  • Accident Year: 2017
  • Publication Year: 2018

I took a 40-foot fall on ice at Chapel Pond, smashed my face, and suffered a traumatic brain injury, but lived to tell about it. It was February 8, and I was guiding Rhiannon, a 200-foot WI4+ line in the Power Play amphitheater, above Chapel Pond. It was a warm day, and I was not feeling well as we headed up to the base. I was moving so slowly while getting ready that my client asked me if I was okay. I told her I didn’t feel great, but I figured I’d be fine as soon as I started climbing.

A lot of people climb Rhiannon in two pitches, but I usually do it in one with 70-meter half ropes. The first part of the climb is a steep slab up to a ledge, then a long vertical piece with a short, steep headwall at the very top.

The ice was wet above the ledge, and I didn’t want my client to have to stop in the dripping ice to take out protection, so I placed my last screw at the ledge (that’s normally how I climb the route anyway). About 20 feet above the ledge, I stopped just below the steepest part of the climb and got ready to place another screw. My tools were firmly planted when it happened: My brain shut down—I short-circuited and blacked out. I didn’t blow out any ice, my tools didn’t pop, my feet didn’t pop. I literally just let go of my tools for a split second. I came to immediately and was very confused. I knew I was falling, but I didn’t know why. I had enough time to think, “This is not going to be good.”

My client said that, watching from below, it looked like I was climbing normally and then she saw my body kind of slump, and then I was off.

I fell about 40 feet and smashed into the ice, face-first, and then slid another 10 to 20 feet. I’m sure there was some rope stretch, as there always is with half ropes. You always fall a lot farther than you think you’re going to. When I hit the ledge I got knocked out, I don’t know for how long, and then I woke up. My first thought when I came to was, “OK, I’m alive.” My second thought was “Holy, s***, there’s a lot of blood.”

My client lowered me to the base and untied me from the rope, and I got up and walked out with her. At the hospital in Burlington, Vermont, the doctors said I had a cerebral hemorrhage and I had broken every plate in my face; I broke my nose in 10 places. I also had some minor soft-tissue injuries. Luckily, my face has healed, and I didn’t need reconstructive surgery. My brain continues to heal.


I’m still not sure why I blacked out, but it was probably a combination of things. I was pushing really hard last season, climbing in the backcountry a lot and just pushing, pushing, pushing. I may have been quite dehydrated as well, and I wasn’t eating well, especially for that kind of output. After my hospitalization, in a follow-up appointment, I had my Vitamin D level tested and it was very low. I don’t know if that had anything to do with the accident, but I’m on a supplement now. I’ve also changed my diet and lost weight. I’m back to climbing hard routes and guiding.

If there’s a lesson here, it’s take care of yourself and pay attention to how you feel. I always had a tendency to push through things and say, “I’ll be fine.” And this day I knew I wasn’t feeling well. This accident made me think about my health and also got me into a renewed frame of mind. It’s sort of like, “Wow, I got another shot, let’s try to be a little smarter about this.” (Source: Matt Horner.)

Editor’s note: Working guides often run it out to make seconding easier for their clients, but the consequences of a mistake or outside factors (rockfall, illness, etc.) can be severe, not just for the guide but potentially the client as well. 

This ANAM article has been reformatted into HTML. Please contact us if you spot an error.

Photos and Topos Click photo to view full size and see caption