American Alpine Jounrna and Accidents in North American Climbing

Rappel Failure, Stranded, Inexperience, California, Yosemite Valley

  • Accident Reports
  • Accident Year:
  • Publication Year: 1982


California, Yosemite Valley

On September 25, 1981 at 3:15 p.m., Rangers Dill, Durr and Reilly responded to a report that Noel Dupre La Tour (27) was stranded at the top of the first pitch of the West Face route on Rixon’s Pinnacle. The stranded climber’s partner John Lang (25) had reportedly fallen to the ground, a distance of about 100 feet, and had taken their climbing ropes with him.

Dill, using the line gun and a number four load, shot a line to the stranded climber; with that line, he was able to haul up enough rope to rappel to the ground.

Upon reaching the ground, La Tour stated that his partner had attempted to rappel on two ropes and that the knot connecting the two ropes came undone. La Tour stated that the knot used was a single fisherman’s. Upon inspection of La Tour’s gear, Durr observed that the ends of a sling attached to one of their Friends were not tied together but merely jammed into the apparatus. Further, Durr observed that the tails of the knots on many of the climber’s slings were encompassed within the knot and not visible. (Source: Jim Reilly, SAR Ranger, Yosemite National Park)


This type of accident has not been reported for years. The double fisherman’s knot is the knot of choice for tying two ends of rope together. The water knot is the knot of choice for tying two ends of webbing together; adequate tails are more crucial because webbing slips more easily. (Source: J. Williamson)

(Editor’s Note: Last year I wrote an analysis of an incident near Rixon’s Pinnacle in Yosemite Valley in which two climbers, Vernon Squire and Michael Caryl, became stranded while attempting to descend at dusk from their climb of the Lower Brother. In a letter addressed to me, Caryl clarified some of the specific details of their predicament. Pertinent excerpts from that letter follow.

“First, we climbed the Southwest Arête of the Lower Brother, a Grade III, 5.5 climb of some 12–14 pitches. We started early, made steady progress and reached the summit by about 3:00 p.m. The ANAM account wholly omits this fact and erroneously states that rangers were dispatched at 1:00 p.m. when we were still on the route. At about 3:30 p.m., we began the descent of Michael’s Ledge. (See A Climber’s Guide to Yosemite Valley by Steve Roper [1971], p. 100.) We had descended more than one half the ledge system, beyond the two large pine trees, and were continuing down the ledge system to the west. Where the guide book says, ‘Where progress becomes improbable, rappel or climb down to an inconspicuous ledge with a cairn,’ we rappelled, though we saw no cairn. At this point, dusk was approaching (this is early April) and the route through the brush seemed to end.

“Our first mistake when westward progress ended was to rappel about 40 feet to a ledge with a large tree. At this point, we could see the steeply-falling walls of Rixon’s Pinnacle. Progress westward was impossible, so we rappelled down the face. Since we had two ropes, we did three more 150-foot rappels, at the end of which my partner Squire hung. The mistake was even rappelling the first time, which mistake was compounded with each successive rappel. The moral: We should have stopped, tied in to the many trees, and spent a comfortable night. Instead, our fourth rappel, at the end of which Vernon hung, was from a somewhat doubtful flake. My stance was on a downsloping sandy ledge measuring about 10 inches by 36 inches, on a 70-degree face.

“The obvious moral of our situation is not to rappel blindly, cutting off avenues of escape. Better to sit out the darkness and resume the descent in daylight.”

The facts in the original report came from Yosemite Valley Park Service. The letter from Caryl demonstrates once again that if the climbers involved in mishaps would provide information directly, greater accuracy and the first person point of view would enhance the reports which appear in this publication.)

This ANAM article has been reformatted into HTML. Please contact us if you spot an error.